WE ARE LIVE. KEEP WRITING. KEEP READING. KEEP REFERRING. KEEP EARNING Withdrawals is being processed, if you've gotten yours kindly post receipts on our Facebook page WE ARE LIVE. KEEP WRITING. KEEP READING. KEEP REFERRING. KEEP EARNING Withdrawals is being processed, if you've gotten yours kindly post receipts on our Facebook page
THE WORST FIRST IMPRESSION
story

THE WORST FIRST IMPRESSION


Chapter Five

Amara spent the rest of the day trying not to think about Adrian

It didn't work

Not even a little

Every time she tried to concentrate on something else, his words from the previous day somehow found their way back into her thoughts

Someone from my past

She had replayed those words so many times that they were starting to sound like a song stuck in her head

She sat in the cafeteria with Tessa, staring down at her lunch

She hadn't taken a single bite

Tessa noticed

“You're doing it again.

Amara looked up

“Doing what?

“Thinking.

“That's generally considered a good thing.

“Not when you've been staring at the same piece of food for ten minutes.

Amara glanced down

Tessa was right

She had been pushing the same piece of food around her plate

“I was distracted.

“By Adrian?

Amara immediately looked at her

“Why does everything have to be about Adrian with you?

“Because everything seems to be about Adrian with you.

“It is not.

Tessa leaned back in her chair, smiling

“Okay.

Amara narrowed her eyes

“Don't do that.

“Do what?

“That little ‘okay’ thing.

“What little ‘okay’ thing?

“The one where you pretend you believe me.

Tessa laughed

“You're impossible.

“So I've been told.

Amara finally picked up her fork

Before she could eat, someone walked past their table

She didn't need to look up to know who it was

Adrian

She glanced sideways

He was walking toward the cafeteria doors, his hands in his pockets and his expression completely unreadable

Then something fell from his jacket

It landed near Amara's chair

He didn't notice

“Hey!

Adrian stopped

He turned around

Amara bent down and picked up the object

It was small and black

She held it up

“You dropped this.

Adrian walked back

The moment he saw what she was holding, something changed in his expression

It was quick

Almost too quick to notice

But Amara noticed

His eyes widened slightly

His shoulders stiffened

Then, just as quickly, his usual calm expression returned

“Thanks.

He reached for it

Amara handed it over

Their fingers touched for the briefest moment

Adrian immediately pulled his hand away

Amara raised an eyebrow

Okay… that was weird

“What is it?

“Nothing.

She looked at the object

“It's clearly something.

“It's just an old key.

“A key?

“Yes.

“A key to what?

Adrian gave her a completely serious look

“A door.

Amara stared at him

Tessa covered her mouth, trying not to laugh

Amara slowly nodded

“Wow.

Adrian waited

“Mystery solved.

For the first time, a small smile appeared on his face

“Exactly.

He slipped the key into his pocket

Then he walked away

Amara watched him leave

Tessa immediately leaned across the table

“What was that?

“I don't know.

“You were flirting.

Amara nearly choked

“I was asking questions!

“That's what people say when they're flirting.

“I do not flirt with arrogant people.

Tessa smiled

“You called him Angry Shirt yesterday.

“Exactly. That's an insult.

“Sure.

Amara rolled her eyes

But she couldn't stop thinking about the key

There had been something about Adrian's reaction

He hadn't looked annoyed

He had looked worried

Why would an old key make him look like that

She looked toward the cafeteria doors

Adrian was already gone

That evening, the university was quieter than usual

Most students had returned to their dorms, while a few remained around the library or student center

Amara walked slowly toward her dorm

She had her headphones around her neck, but no music was playing

She was thinking

Again

I really need to stop thinking so much

She reached the university gate

Then she stopped

A black car was parked nearby

Something about it looked familiar

Amara frowned

Probably nothing

She continued walking

Then the driver's door opened

A man stepped out

Amara's steps slowed

She recognized him

The stranger from the hallway

The same man she'd seen with Adrian

Her stomach tightened

Why is he here

She quickly stepped behind a nearby tree

The man looked around before walking toward the library

Amara watched him carefully

A few seconds later, another figure appeared

Adrian

He was walking from the opposite direction

The two men stopped several feet apart

Neither spoke for several seconds

Amara couldn't hear what they were saying

But she could see Adrian's face

He looked different

Not arrogant

Not annoyed

Not even angry

Worried

The stranger reached inside his coat

Amara held her breath

He pulled out a photograph

He handed it to Adrian

Adrian stared at it

His expression became completely still

Amara leaned forward slightly

What is that

She couldn't see the front of the photograph

But when Adrian turned it over, she noticed something written on the back

A name

One name

Her name

AMARA

Her breath caught

My name

She stared at it

For a moment, she couldn't move

That's impossible

Adrian suddenly looked in her direction

Amara ducked behind the tree

Her heart pounded

She pressed herself against the trunk and held her breath

Footsteps

Then silence

She waited several seconds before slowly looking around the tree

The two men were gone

The black car was still there

Amara stepped out from behind the tree

She looked toward the library

Nothing

She looked toward the gate

Nothing

Where did they go

She took a few cautious steps forward

Then stopped

She didn't know what frightened her more—the fact that Adrian had a photograph connected to her, or the fact that he seemed to know something she didn't

She hugged her notebook against her chest

Maybe it's a coincidence

She shook her head

No

There were too many coincidences

The stranger

The key

The secret conversations

The photograph

And now her name

Amara looked toward the dark library windows

For the first time, she wondered whether Adrian had been trying to protect her from something

or keep her from discovering something

She took a slow breath

Maybe Adrian's secret had nothing to do with me

She looked back at the empty road where the black car had been

Maybe it had everything to do with me

And somehow, she knew one thing for certain

She wasn't going to stop asking questions

Not now. .......…..............?.................?.......?......................?.......................?.....”””.”””.”””....”.”.”...”.”””””.””......”........”.....”.........””.”””””.”.”””.””...””””.”.........eNe:

She looked back at the empty road where the black car had been.

Maybe it had everything to do with me.

And somehow, she knew one thing for certain.

She wasn't going to stop asking questions.

Not now.

Copyright © 2026 Freda🥂🥰 on Writers Arena. This content may not be republished or reproduced without permission.
Login to react
This read isn't counted yet — sign up free (or log in) and it'll count toward your earnings, right now and on every post after.

Comments (2)

Mabel (@bensonmfoniso7) 01/10/2026
lovely!
Freda🥂🥰 (@olowoabike2) 12/10/2026
Thank you 🥰

Leave a comment

Login to comment on this post.
About the author
Freda🥂🥰
@olowoabike2
Storyteller
Abuja
Just a girl with big imagination,turning random ideas into stories ✍🏾✨

Continue reading

Previous
Why You Should Pay Attention to Frequent Headaches
Home
Next
Welcome To October